In most sexually reproducing species with active mate choice, signaling and receiver systems are highly complex entities; male cues are often hierarchical in nature, consisting of a variety of traits for female assessment within each sensory modality (e.g. visual signals such as size, behaviour, colour), each one of which may in turn be composed of several different elements (e.g. the hue, chroma, intensity or pattern of colour). In addition, both within and among populations, females can vary in their response to both single male traits and multi-component signals in complicated ways. Between populations, geographic variation in trait-preference complexes can result in a variety of mate choice scenarios ranging from partial, or asymmetric, to complete positive assortative mating. For example, if interpopulation divergence in female preferences closely tracks divergence in male traits, then genetically co-varying signal-preference complexes can lead to behavioural isolation and, ultimately, speciation. However, reproductive isolation between groups may be constrained if mean female preference values and male signals fail to co-evolve in concert, the specific outcome of which will depend on the strength and form of the trait-preference relationship. My research examines the general mechanisms by which the shape and form of multiple, hierarchically arranged, within-population female preferences functions, combined with divergence in male traits, influence both intraspecific and interspecific reproductive dynamics.
Figure: An example of geographic variability in both male and female nuptial color patterns in two populations of Brook stickleback (Culaea inconstans).